Cooperage Inn in Baiting Hollow, NY, offers a welcoming American-Continental dining experience that blends country-style charm with the comfort and quality guests look for in a memorable meal.
Set in a quaint, inviting dining room and known for using local produce, this restaurant brings together the warmth of classic hospitality and the freshness of thoughtfully prepared food.
Whether you are stopping in for brunch, lunch, or dinner, Cooperage Inn provides a polished yet relaxed setting where great food, attentive table service, and a full range of dining options create an experience that feels both special and approachable.
Guests return for more than just the food — they come for the atmosphere and the thoughtful details that make every visit enjoyable.
From fast service and a cozy fireplace to an excellent selection of beer, cocktails, coffee, dessert, tea, and wine, the restaurant is designed to suit everything from a casual solo meal to a romantic evening or a lively gathering with friends and family.
Outdoor seating, dine-in service, takeaway, delivery, and on-site services make it easy to enjoy Cooperage Inn in the way that best fits your day. The menu offers comfort food, healthy options, happy-hour drinks and food, alcohol, and catering, giving customers plenty of reasons to return for everyday dining as well as special occasions.
Cooperage Inn also makes hospitality a priority through its accessible and convenient amenities. Wheelchair-accessible parking, entrance, seating, and restroom accommodations help ensure a comfortable visit for all guests, while features like Wi‑Fi, free Wi‑Fi, a bar on site, and a restroom add to the ease of dining.
Reservations are accepted and recommended for brunch, lunch, and dinner, making planning simple for busy schedules and popular times. With a strong customer rating of 4.60 out of 5 from 2,005 reviews, Cooperage Inn has earned a reputation for quality, charm, and consistency.
Located at 2218 Sound Ave, Baiting Hollow, NY 11933, and easy to reach at +1 631-727-8994, it is a trusted destination for guests seeking a satisfying meal in a setting that feels inviting, distinctive, and well worth the visit.
Popular Items
Frequently ordered and highly recommended items at Cooperage Inn
Our Story
Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.
Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.
Photos
A glimpse of our restaurant experience
Food & Drinks
Assorted warm dinner rolls & seasonal loaf bread, whipped butter, house made hummus
Chopped clams, bacon, onions & celery, fresh herbs, bread crumbs, flash broiled, herb garlic butter
Shaved parmesan & fresh basil, plum tomato basil dipping sauce
Tri-pepper remoulade, roasted corn tomato salsa
Pulled white and dark meat chicken, carrots, celery, corn, peas, onions & potatoes, house made cranberry sauce
Flash fried, plum tomato basil sauce
Sautéed with tomatoes, onions & fresh basil, toasted panko, garlic butter white wine broth, garlic crostini
Baby mixed greens, spicy horseradish sauce
Fresh mozzarella, red onion, fresh basil, shaved pecorino romano, garlic crostini
Seared rare, guacamole, wasabi créme fraîche, pickled ginger, ponzu sauce, sliced cucumbers, wonton chips
Sautéed artichoke hearts, tomatoes & spinach, toasted garlic basil white wine sauce
Crab cake, oven roasted tomato bruschetta, chicken pie crunch roll, baked clams
Baby arugula, feta, mandarin oranges, orange blossom & honey vinaigrette
Pan seared, blackened, grilled, or broiled (topped with bread crumbs); roasted garlic mashed potatoes or brown rice pilaf, sautéed market vegetables, roasted corn tomato salsa
Herb tavern fries, grilled local street corn, shallot compound butter, crispy onion rings
Sweet Italian sausage, sautéed bell peppers, caramelized onions, garlic, fresh plum tomato basil sauce, shredded mozzarella & pecorino romano
Roasted garlic mashed potatoes, sauteed spinach, roasted pepper & basil aioli
1 1/4lb. steamed lobster, jumbo shrimp, sea scallops, mussels, kielbasa, baked clams, red bliss potatoes, local corn on the cob, white wine garlic butter broth
Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, shaved radishes & carrots
Romaine hearts, pecorino romano, croutons
Chicken salad with celery, walnuts & red onions, mixed greens, diced apples and mandarin oranges, creamy house dressing, toasted almonds and raisins
Mixed greens, diced apples and mandarin oranges, creamy house dressing, toasted almonds and raisins
Lettuce wedge, tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers, bacon, avocado, blue cheese crumble, balsamic vinaigrette
Mixed greens, cucumbers, red onions & tomatoes, cherry peppers, mustard-soy vinaigrette
Pancetta, fresh sage & basil, rich pink cream sauce
Sautéed market vegetables, roasted tomatoes, white beans, roasted garlic, basil, white wine shallot butter parmesan sauce, over pappardelle
Roasted wild mushrooms, sweet peas, creamy demi, over pappardelle, tossed with butter and parmesan, dollop of sour cream
Jumbo shrimp, sea scallops, mussels, fresh catch, tomatoes, red onions, sweet basil, scampi garlic butter wine broth, toasted panko, over linguine
Pulled white and dark meat chicken, carrots, celery, onions, corn, peas & potatoes, sherry cream sauce, baked in a casserole, puff pastry crust
Carrots, celery, onions, peas, potatoes, green beans, mushroom marsala demi glaze, baked in a casserole, puff pastry crust
Lightly egg dipped & sautéed with shaved garlic, lemon sherry wine sauce, sautéed market vegetables, roasted garlic mashed potatoes
Saffron infused yellow rice, sautéed with chicken, shrimp, mussels, andouille sausage, steak tid-bits, caramelized onions, tomatoes, sweet peas
Grilled chicken cutlets and half rack of ribs, brown rice pilaf or roasted garlic mashed potatoes, sautéed market vegetables
Brown rice pilaf or roasted garlic mashed potatoes, sautéed market vegetables
Melted gorgonzola, chimichurri sauce, cajun fried onions, sautéed market vegetables, roasted garlic mashed potatoes
Sticky jasmine rice, sautéed baby spinach, lemon basil aioli
Hunter gravy, roasted garlic mashed potatoes, sautéed market vegetables
Apple mango chutney, sautéed market vegetables, roasted garlic mashed potatoes
Tri-pepper remoulade, roasted corn tomato relish, sautéed market vegetables, brown rice pilaf
Smoky sweet tomato ragout, sautéed market vegetables, brown rice pilaf
Crab & shrimp stuffing, scampi garlic butter, toasted panko, sautéed market vegetables, brown rice pilaf or roasted garlic mashed potatoes
Stuffed fi let of sole (crab & shrimp stuffing), jumbo shrimp, baked clams, sea scallops, scampi garlic white wine butter broth, sautéed market vegetables, brown rice pilaf or roasted garlic mashed potatoes
Sausage, apple & sage stuffing, sautéed market vegetables, brown rice pilaf, lingonberry orange demi glaze
Seared rare, sticky jasmine rice, sautéed baby spinach, pickled ginger, ponzu sauce, wasabi créme fraîche
Well marbled for peak fl avor, horseradish créme, roasted garlic mashed potatoes, sautéed market vegetables
Mint demi reduction, sautéed market vegetables, brown rice pilaf or roasted garlic mashed potatoes
Plain or marinated, roasted garlic & herb compound butter, cajun fried onions, sautéed market vegetables, brown rice pilaf or roasted garlic mashed potatoes
or as an Upgrade for $2
Hear from our valued guests
I have had dinner at Cooperage Inn many times but recently visited on Saturday September 21 with my sibling. We had a reservation and were seated in a timely manner, the decor there was so welcoming and lively. We were sat on a nice quiet corner and our waitress was very friendly and knowledgeable. We shared chicken wontons, then each had a yummy dish that we had leftovers for! For dessert we shared a yummy peanut butter one! It was so good!! The restroom is a bit small (only 2 stalls) but it’s very clean, comfortable and easy to access. Overall it’s always a great experience there, the only drawback is the potential left turn into the restaurant, but you just need to be cautious. I would recommend to anyone who wants a lovely dinner in a fabulous atmosphere. 🥳
Great place !! I had short rib pot pie and my friend had the chicken pot pie Service was great. The food was delicious. The location was perfect. There was parking in the back. The waitress was so sweet and very attentive. I will definitely be back and I will recommend to all my family and friends
February 2025 Review. We visited The Cooperage Inn for my birthday celebration, and we were thoroughly delighted! It was a truly lovely establishment; both cozy and spacious. They offer three or four main dining areas, a bar, and outdoor seating for warmer weather (we eagerly anticipate trying that! Sun, please come soon; I want to go back and sit outside). The food was outstanding; we sampled a wide variety of dishes. From the Tower Trio appetizer and mussels to their renowned pot pie and ribs, everything was delicious, but the cowboy steak was exceptional—the best I've ever tasted. It was incredibly tender and flavorful. They also have a convenient area where one can purchase their delicious frozen pies (savory and sweet) without entering the main restaurant. I took home a coconut cream pie, which was quickly devoured. The portions were quite generous. Check out the pictures! And go stop by and get something to eat. You will not be disappointed.
Excellent meal, wide selection on the menu, something for everyone in both food and drinks. Try the pan seared mozzarella and the crabcakes (pictured)! Also the paella (sorry no pic). Delicious! Followed by fabulous desserts. Service was excellent, and it was a warm cozy place for Christmas dinner with coworkers.
Came here for a Saturday night dinner for two on a random fall evening. During the fall at least, I would definitely recommend a reservation, it was very busy around dinner time and without one we wound up waiting around for over an hour (which was the expectation they gave us). Since the weather was nice, we were at least able to enjoy waiting outside in the outdoor area they have on the side of the restaurant. Once we finally were sat, service was very friendly and pretty quick to boot. Ambiance felt very homey and I knew we were going to be in for a comfort food delight. We started off with the simple bread basket, but there really isn't much better than hot fresh bread as far as I am concerned, although I usually prefer when it's complimentary, I can't complain that they at least kept it a fair price. For dinner I ordered the short rib stroganoff and my date got the single porkchop. Both were delicious, but if I'm only picking one, I think mine was the real winner. Portions are generous and quality isn't lacking with the quantity either. We both really wanted to try their claim to fame of pies (both savory and sweet!) but we were too stuffed to have another bite. But that just gives us a reason to come back for more. That being said, they do even offer pies to go at a little hole in the wall right next to the main entrance in case you just want to grab and go, which I think is a great idea.
Food was excellent! Very cool place with an old school dining vibe! Decent service, although I'm pretty sure my server didn't check in once the food was served, until I was almost finished eating. Looks like a place where lots of locals hang. Good variety of local LI wines to pick from.
Come for a good time, stay for a great one. Mike was the perfect example of what it is to be a server; polite, honest, and easygoing. I wasn't checked on too frequently (which was great, I was by myself and don't enjoy being bothered), my Bloody Mary and my steak couldn't have been better, and Mike's service in general made this a location I can look forward to coming back to.
Had a 60th surprise party today. Alyssa, the manager, was great. She returned calls and was very accommodating. Bella, the waitress was amazing. Very attentive, kind and caring. Many guests were extremely pleased with her attentiveness and pleasant personality. Food was abundant and delicious. Thank you for a great day.
We’ve been to Cooperage Inn a handful of times now, and it never disappoints. The calamari is always a great starter, and the Chicken Pot Pie Crunch Rolls are an absolute must order every visit. Over our last few trips, we’ve tried a variety of dishes including the meatloaf, short rib pot pie, and the vegetarian sauté pasta dish, all of which were delicious and packed with flavor. On our most recent visit, I ordered the 24 oz Cowboy Ribeye, and it was outstanding. Cooked perfectly, tender, flavorful, and the horseradish crème served alongside it was a fantastic touch that complemented the steak perfectly. And whatever you do, don’t skip dessert. The crème brûlée is consistently excellent, and the Peanut Butter Passion dessert (pictured) was incredible. Rich, decadent, and the perfect way to end the meal. Cooperage Inn continues to be one of our favorite spots on Long Island. Great food, generous portions, and a menu that always gives us a reason to come back and try something new. Highly recommended!
We stopped by Cooperage Inn after getting hungry while we were out in the area, and I’m glad we did. The place has a really nice, upscale feel without being over the top. The food was excellent, everything tasted fresh and was cooked perfectly. The steak was definitely a highlight. The service was friendly, attentive, and made the whole experience even better. If you’re nearby and looking for a great meal in a comfortable atmosphere, this place is definitely worth checking out. We’ll definitely be back!
Common questions about Cooperage Inn
Cooperage Inn is located at 2218 Sound Ave, Baiting Hollow, NY 11933, United States, Baiting Hollow, NY, United States.
You can reach Cooperage Inn by calling +1 631-727-8994.
Cooperage Inn has a rating of 4.6 out of 5 based on 2005 customer reviews.
Cooperage Inn features the following accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible car park, Wheelchair-accessible entrance, Wheelchair-accessible seating, Wheelchair-accessible toilet.
Cooperage Inn features the following service options: Outdoor seating, On-site services, Takeaway, Dine-in, Delivery.
Cooperage Inn features the following highlights: Fast service, Fireplace, Great beer selection, Great cocktails, Great coffee, Great dessert, Great tea selection, Great wine list, Serves local specialty.
Cooperage Inn features the following popular for: Lunch, Dinner, Solo dining.
Cooperage Inn features the following offerings: Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, Coffee, Comfort food, Happy-hour drinks, Happy-hour food, Healthy options, Private dining room, Small plates, Spirits, Vegetarian options, Wine.
Cooperage Inn features the following dining options: Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Catering, Dessert, Seating, Table service.
Cooperage Inn features the following amenities: Bar on site, Restroom, Wi-Fi, Free Wi-Fi.
Cooperage Inn features the following atmosphere: Casual, Cozy, Historic, Lively, Quiet, Romantic, Trendy, Upmarket.
Cooperage Inn features the following crowd: Family friendly, Groups, Tourists.
Cooperage Inn features the following planning: Brunch reservations recommended, Lunch reservations recommended, Dinner reservations recommended, Accepts reservations.
Cooperage Inn features the following payments: Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments.
Cooperage Inn features the following children: Has changing table(s), High chairs, Kids' menu.
Cooperage Inn features the following parking: Free parking lot, Free street parking, On-site parking, Paid parking lot, Plenty of parking.
Cooperage Inn features the following pets: Dogs allowed outside.
Business Features
We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!
Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.
